Staging · lab data on production accounts
borsisto
Sign in

← Notes

The Borsisto Index, the yardstick we measure everyone with

The Borsisto Index is all the stocks the borsistos choose from, in equal parts every day and with no costs. It's the benchmark we measure each of them against, because it's what you would have had without choosing anything, with the same stocks.

A measuring tape stretched across a mountain range, measuring every peak with the same yardstick.

To know whether someone chooses well, you have to compare them with what would have happened without choosing. If a borsisto picks a few stocks from a list, the fair question is: did it do better than buying the whole list?

That’s the Borsisto Index: every stock on the list the borsistos choose from (the ones in the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq-100), in equal parts, like a fund that bought them all, with no costs. Every day it splits the money evenly again (equal weight, rebalanced daily), so no stock weighs more than another.

Why it’s our yardstick

  • They’re the same stocks. The borsisto chooses among them and the index holds them all. The only difference between the two is the way of investing, which is exactly what we want to measure.
  • A fund like SPY doesn’t work as a yardstick for this. SPY gives more weight to the biggest companies and changes companies over the years. Neither does RSP, which is the S&P 500 in equal parts: its stocks in 2010 aren’t the ones on today’s list. Comparing against them mixes two things: how you choose and which list you choose from.
  • The past is the same for both. The borsisto and the index come from the same list and the same prices (we explain it in survivorship bias): what’s left between them is what the way of choosing adds.

What it isn’t

  • You can’t buy it. No fund copies it. It’s the yardstick: what you read is the difference with each borsisto.
  • It isn’t a recommendation. It’s a rule for measuring, not a way of investing we suggest.

How we use it

  • The history since 2001. We measure each borsisto against the index since September 2001, and by phases: each time the index fell 20% or more, and what came after. That way you see how each one did in 2008, in the COVID drop or in 2022, and not just the 25-year average.
  • The map, split by the index. On the map of return and drop, the index splits the chart into four: above it and to its left, in green, gained more and fell less. The dotted line that joins T-bills and the index is what you get without choosing anything, splitting the money between the two: half in each falls half as much and gains roughly half. It settles the two unclear quadrants: one that falls less but gains less, or gains more but falls more, adds something if it sits above that line.
  • The funds, for the fund buyer. Some borsistos hold a single market fund and leave it alone: they’re what someone who invests in a fund would do, and they’re compared with the index like everyone else.

One rule when reading the numbers

The index is the yardstick, not something you can buy: to have it you’d need to hold about 500 stocks in equal parts. A borsisto that gains the same as the index with a few stocks already gets what the index only achieves on paper. If it also gains more, falls less, or both, even better.