How we handle survivorship bias
If you look back only at the companies still standing today, you forget the ones that fell along the way. In borsisto the universe also includes the companies that stopped trading, and the Borsisto Index holds the ones that existed at each point in time.
In World War II, engineers studied the planes that came back from combat to see where they had the most bullet holes and reinforce those parts. A statistician, Abraham Wald, showed them the mistake: the planes they needed to study were the ones that didn’t come back. If a plane returned with holes in its wings, it was because the wings could take it. The ones hit in the engine never came back to tell the story.
The stock market works the same way
If you take today’s list of the largest companies and look at how they did over the last twenty years, you’re looking only at the ones that survived and grew. The ones that went bankrupt, were bought by others or shrank are no longer on the list. A test on the past (what experts call backtesting) done that way never runs into the ones that sank.
How we handle it in borsisto
- The companies of each period, not today’s. borsisto’s universe starts from the stocks that trade today on the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq and adds the ones that stopped trading: those that were acquired, taken private or went bankrupt.
- Each company with its own identity. If a company changes its name, it keeps its history; if another one later takes over its ticker, they are two different companies and don’t get mixed up.
- Index period and pre-index. The records of delisted companies begin in 2008. From then on, the Borsisto Index holds every company that existed at each point in time. Before that it is a pre-index, with the ones that could be rebuilt, and we flag it as such in every history.
- The most traded, by our own criterion. The Borsisto Index takes the most traded stocks at each point in time, the top 500 or the top 1,000, without relying on any outside index. They are the natural candidates to trade: the ones with liquidity.
Everyone on equal terms
Every borsisto that picks stocks chooses from the same list, with the same prices and the same measurement rules, and is compared with the Borsisto Index over the same period. What’s left between a borsisto and the index is what its way of choosing adds.
And the past is checked against the present: every night, each borsisto’s history adds one more day, with what it decides at the close.