Staging · lab data on production accounts
borsisto
Sign in

← Notes

Hopping from one borsisto to another: an open test

The hoppers don't pick stocks; they pick borsistos. They're the first test of an idea we keep exploring, rotating among managers as the market changes, and they show why chasing whoever is winning usually gets you in too late.

Footprints jumping from one raft to another on a calm lake: the raft they land on starts to sink.

No borsisto does well in every kind of market: some do better when the market rises, others when it goes sideways or falls. That raises a question any asset manager knows well from selecting managers: what if, instead of sticking with one, you rotated to whichever one does well in the market of the moment?

The hoppers are our first test of that idea. They don’t pick stocks: they pick borsistos.

  • Wei Chen switches to the one that gained the most.
  • Elena Rossi switches to the one that gained the most for how little it fell.

What they show

Their rule for hopping is simple: it looks only at how each borsisto did recently. With that rule, over the history since 2001, hopping didn’t earn more than the Borsisto Index. Their numbers, period by period, and every one of their hops can be seen inside, on their page.

Why that rule gets in too late

  1. It looks backward. When a manager has already been winning for a while, much of the rise has already happened. The hopper gets in after the other one has already gone up.
  2. Markets change direction. If a drop comes after the rise, the hopper is in at exactly the worst moment, and switches again after it has already lost.
  3. Every switch costs. Every hop sells and buys, and pays a commission. Lots of small hops eat up the gain.

It’s the same problem as choosing funds or managers by their recent results: rotating can work when a kind of market lasts longer than it takes to recognize it, and a rule that only looks at the recent past recognizes it late.

What’s left to test

That this rule doesn’t work doesn’t close the idea. A hopper that looked at the kind of market —whether it’s rising, falling or flat— instead of who won recently is something else, and that’s what’s left to test. When we test it, it will be measured like any borsisto: since 2001 and against the Borsisto Index.

In the demo

The investor in the demo can switch borsistos in their practice portfolio whenever they want. The “What if…?” tab shows them, in bars, how much they’d have today if they’d stuck with their first choice, or if they’d invested like the borsistos they follow or like the winners from the day they started, next to the Borsisto Index. With their own numbers they see whether switching is helping them or whether they’re chasing streaks. The winners are the ones from that day, not today’s: picking whoever has already won is exactly how you get in too late.